Baking Up Broadway: A Heartfelt Review of ‘Waitress: The Musical’ on HBO Max
Waitress: The Musical made its HBO Max debut as a heartwarming, emotionally charged performance that brings the beloved Broadway show to home audiences. Based on Adrienne Shelly’s 2007 film, the musical follows Jenna Hunterson, a waitress and expert pie maker, trapped in a difficult marriage in a small town. The story explores themes of love, independence, and friendship, set against the backdrop of deliciously crafted pies. With music and lyrics by Sara Bareilles, this adaptation captures the magic of the stage production while offering a fresh, intimate experience through the lens of film.
[Warning: spoilers from the Waitress Proshot are below!]
Jenna finds her footing in Waitress: The Musical
The plot centers on Jenna, played by composer-lyricist Sara Bareilles herself, who finds herself stuck in a dead-end marriage to the controlling, abusive Earl (Dakin Matthews). Despite her circumstances, Jenna finds solace in her love for baking pies, which serves as both a creative outlet and a means of survival. When a local baking contest offers a potential escape, Jenna begins to consider the possibility of a new life, one where she can assert control over her own destiny.
Bareilles, no stranger to musical theater, brings authenticity to Jenna, infusing the role with vulnerability and strength. Her performance of “She Used to Be Mine,” the musical’s centerpiece song, is a standout moment in the production, delivering a raw emotional impact that captures Jenna’s internal struggle. Bareilles’ vocal prowess and stage presence are undeniable, and she successfully anchors the show, guiding the audience through Jenna’s transformation.
The supporting cast plays an equally pivotal role in the success of Waitress. Charity Angél Dawson shines as Becky, Jenna’s best friend and co-worker, bringing humor and heart to the production. Caitlin Houlahan’s portrayal of Dawn, another waitress at the diner, adds a touch of quirkiness that balances the narrative’s more serious undertones. Drew Gehling as Dr. Pomatter, Jenna’s love interest, brings a charming, awkward energy to his character, and his chemistry with Bareilles is palpable, adding a layer of sweetness to the otherwise difficult journey Jenna faces.
The music is truly the star of this HBO Max proshot
The musical numbers, a key component of the show, are energetic, emotional, and memorable. Bareilles’ songwriting shines through in tracks like “Opening Up,” “When He Sees Me,” and the aforementioned “She Used to Be Mine,” each of which encapsulates the musical’s central emotional themes. The songs blend pop, jazz, and Broadway styles seamlessly, making them instantly catchy and accessible to a wide audience. The music resonates on a deep level, whether it’s the empowering anthems or the more subdued ballads, all of which are performed with heart and sincerity.
Director Diane Paulus and the creative team have crafted a visually dynamic experience, even within the confines of the film adaptation. The stage’s design and lighting are utilized in such a way that they transform the theater into a living, breathing space, heightening the emotional stakes of the story. While the production maintains a relatively minimalist set, focusing on a central diner and a few key locations, the clever use of color and lighting adds depth to the scenes. The intimacy of the filmed performance brings a new layer of connection between the actors and the audience, allowing for close-ups and personal moments that might otherwise be missed in a traditional theater setting.
The themes of Waitress are universal and timeless. At its heart, it’s a story about self-discovery, finding one’s voice, and reclaiming independence. Jenna’s journey is not just about escaping an abusive relationship, but about learning to love herself again and standing up for her own happiness. It’s a tale of friendship and the support system that helps Jenna find the strength to take control of her life. The pie, symbolic of both Jenna’s talents and her personal struggles, becomes a metaphor for the layers of her character: sweet, intricate, and complex.
The film’s pacing is well-maintained, with the musical’s runtime of just over two hours flying by quickly, thanks to the infectious songs and compelling performances. The transition from stage to screen has been thoughtfully executed, with dynamic cinematography that captures the essence of the live show while maintaining the intimacy of a film. For those who have seen the musical live, the Apple TV adaptation offers a chance to relive the magic, while newcomers will find themselves drawn into Jenna’s emotional journey and the musical’s heartwarming tone.
Waitress is currently streaming on HBO Max! Have you watched this proshot before? Let us know on social media @BoxSeatBabes!
History in Harmony: Why Hamilton on Disney+ is a Must-See
