Spare Parts, Full Heart: ‘Maybe Happy Ending’ Is a Warm Glitch
Walking into Maybe Happy Ending for the first time, I expected something sweet, quirky, and lightly futuristic, like a rom-com with a glow-up and a few cute gadgets. What I did not expect was a musical that quietly sneaks up behind you, taps you on the shoulder, and then asks a genuinely unsettling question: If something was built to be temporary, does that make its love temporary too? That is the emotional engine of this show, and it is why the piece has become such a standout in the current Broadway landscape. This production, directed by Michael Arden, leans into a kind of high-end intimacy. It is visually meticulous, musically distinctive, and emotionally sharp in its refusal to treat its central relationship as a novelty. The official framing calls it “a new musical reminding us that love is never obsolete,” and honestly, that line is not just marketing. It is the thesis, and the show commits to it.
[Warning: Spoilers from Maybe Happy Ending are below!]
What Maybe Happy Ending is doing, and why it works
Maybe Happy Ending is a case study in controlled precision. It runs about 1 hour and 40 minutes with no intermission, and that decision matters because the storytelling never loses momentum. There is no “reset” point where the spell breaks and you check your phone and come back as a slightly different person. You are in it, and the show keeps tightening its emotional grip until it lands exactly where it wants to land. It is also staged at the Belasco Theatre, a house that can hold spectacle, but this show uses spectacle like a scalpel, not a sledgehammer. The design team, including Dane Laffrey (scenic and additional video design) and George Reeve (video and projection design), builds a world that feels both warm and slightly uncanny, like a memory you can almost touch but not fully trust.
Here is the simplest, spoiler-respectful version. The musical originated in South Korea and is set in a near-future Seoul, where “helper bots” exist as companions and assistants. Two of those bots, Oliver and Claire, are living in a space meant for the left behind models, and a chance encounter sparks a relationship that becomes deeper than either of them expects. That premise could have played as a gimmick. Instead, the show treats it like human drama, just with different wiring. What lands is the way the musical frames romance as a form of defiance against expiration dates. The story is not simply “robots fall in love.” It is “two beings, told in subtle ways that their best days are behind them, decide to risk connection anyway.” That choice makes the show feel quietly radical. Around them are a handful of characters who expand the world and keep the plot moving without turning it into clutter. It is a small cast with big emotional reach, which makes the whole evening feel like you are watching a delicate machine do something impossibly human.
Maybe Happy Ending does not sound like most Broadway musicals. It is not trying to win you over with constant vocal fireworks or wall-to-wall power belting. The score and lyrics are by Will Aronson and Hue Park, and the writing favors clarity, mood, and emotional specificity over big musical theatre punctuation. That choice is exactly why it works. The music feels like it belongs to this world. It can be playful, romantic, and wistful without pushing. It lets silence matter. It lets hesitation matter. And because the show is about connection, about the bravery of reaching for someone when you are not sure you are built for it, the sound has to support that emotional delicacy. Also, shoutout to Peter Hylenski’s sound design, because this is the kind of score where detail is everything. When a show is inviting you into intimacy, you cannot afford muddy storytelling or swallowed lyrics.
Performances that pulled me into this Tony Award-winning show
Oliver (Darren Criss) is a deceptively hard role. If you play him too robotically, the audience stays outside the story, observing. If you play him too human, the concept loses its edge. The performance works because it balances awkwardness with sincerity. Oliver is not “cute.” He is specific. He is cautious. He is lonely in a way that feels familiar, like the kind of loneliness that comes from being functional but unseen.
Claire (Helen J. Shen) is the spark that keeps the show from becoming soft-focus melancholy. She brings an alertness, a point of view, and a kind of emotional intelligence that make Claire feel fully alive, even when the script reminds you that she is a product with limitations. Claire is not written as a manic pixie upgrade. She is written as someone who has learned to protect herself, and the performance makes that defense feel earned rather than performative.
Then you have Gil Brentley (Dez Duron), who adds a needed shift in energy. Gil’s presence helps the world feel broader, funnier, and a little more unpredictable, which is crucial because a show this tender needs contrast to avoid collapsing under its own softness.
And James and others (Marcus Choi) serve as connective tissue, shaping the story’s context with a grounded, smart performance that keeps the musical from floating away into pure mood.
Why Maybe Happy Ending hits right now
This is where Maybe Happy Ending stops being “a charming sci-fi romance” and starts feeling like a mirror. We are living in a moment where technology is selling companionship, selling optimization, and selling convenience that looks like care. We are also living in a moment when people feel replaceable at work, online, and occasionally in relationships. This musical takes that modern anxiety and translates it into theatre language: two beings designed to serve, discarded when they are no longer useful, trying to prove they are still worthy of love.
It also speaks to planned obsolescence, not just in devices, but in how society treats bodies, careers, and relevance. The show asks what happens when you internalize the idea that you are past your prime. It asks what it takes to risk joy anyway. And because it does all of this with humor and warmth, it never turns into a lecture. It just hurts you politely, then hands you a little hope. There is a reason the production can brag about awards and still feel, in the room, like a personal secret. It is a major critical success, with major recognition at the Tony Awards, but the emotional experience remains intimate.
If you are the type of theatre-goer who wants constant plot fireworks or a traditional Broadway “button” every few minutes, this show might feel too quiet at times. It trusts stillness. It trusts tone. It trusts that you will lean in. For me, that is its strength. But it is worth saying: this is not a loud night out. This is a tender night out.
Know before you go
- Venue: Belasco Theatre, 111 West 44th Street (between 6th and 7th Ave), New York, NY 10036.
- Run time: 1 hour 40 minutes, no intermission.
- Age guidance: Recommended for ages 8 and up. Children under 4 are not permitted.
- Typical weekly schedule: Usually 8 performances a week. A common week looks like Tue 7 pm; Wed 2 pm and 7 pm; Thu 7 pm; Fri 7 pm; Sat 2 pm and 7 pm; Sun 1 pm. Times can shift by week, so always double-check your specific ticket.
- Run status: No end date is listed in the show’s public info, so plan based on the performance calendar that’s currently on sale.
Tickets and box office
- Official tickets: Buy through Telecharge online, or in person at the theatre box office.
- Box office hours: Mon–Sat 10 am–8 pm. Sun noon–6 pm (and may stay open until curtain if there’s an evening performance).
- Phone help: Telecharge customer service and the box office phone line are listed in the show FAQ and ticket info if you need support close to performance time.
- Refund policy: Ticket sales are final. Exchanges and refunds are generally not offered unless a performance is canceled.
Budget options
- Digital lottery: “Club 2064” digital lottery offers a chance to buy up to two $20.64 tickets (drawings the day before each performance at 10 am and 3 pm ET).
- In-person rush: Limited day of rush tickets at the box office for $49 (fees included), first-come, first-served.
- Standing room: Select sold-out performances may offer standing room tickets at the box office for $49 (fees included).
Arrival, policies, and accessibility
- When to arrive: The theatre opens 30 minutes before the curtain.
- Recording policy: No photos, video, or audio recording during the performance.
- What to bring: Expect bag checks. No outside food or beverages, and avoid large luggage or bulky bags when possible.
- Accessibility notes: The main entrance has two small steps, but there is a step-free side entrance if needed. There are no elevators or escalators in the building. Assisted listening options, including mobile captioning and audio description, are available via GalaPro, and devices are also available through Shubert Audience Services.
Casting heads up
- Alternate dates: On select performances, the role of Oliver is scheduled to be played by Steven Huynh or Christopher James Tamayo, so check your performance notes if you are going for a specific lead.
If you want the most current performance calendar and cast notes, the show’s official FAQ and ticket pages keep those details up to date. Have you seen it yet? Tag @bsb.insider with your thoughts.
Final verdict on Maybe Happy Ending
As someone who walked in without prior attachment, I left convinced that Maybe Happy Ending is one of those rare musicals that feels both contemporary and timeless. It is sleek without being cold. It is romantic without being corny. It is smart without being smug. And it understands that the most futuristic idea onstage is not a robot. It is the belief that connection is worth the risk, even when the world tells you your expiration date is approaching. If you want a Broadway night that feels like a warm light in your chest and a quiet ache in your throat, this is the one.
Want the most up to date cast and schedule info, check the official show site. Have you seen it yet? What did you think? Tell us and tag @bsb.insider on social media.
Exclusive Interview: Cast of St. Dunstan’s A Jukebox for the Algonquin
