FeaturesFilmReviews

‘Ebenezer’ is A Christmas Carol That Can’t Decide Whether to Frighten or Delight

Share this with a friend!

Imagine watching an 80-year-old Jack Sparrow stumble through Charles Dickens’ A Christmas Carol, complete with exaggerated mannerisms, a few frightening encounters, and an identity crisis that extends far beyond its main character. That’s probably the best way I can describe my experience watching Ebenezer, the latest cinematic adaptation of one of the most recognizable holiday stories ever written.

Directed by Ti West and starring Johnny Depp as Ebenezer Scrooge, the film promises a darker, more sinister interpretation of the classic Christmas tale. And while I understand what the filmmakers were trying to do, the execution left me wondering one thing: Who exactly was this movie made for? As someone who has seen just about every adaptation of A Christmas Carol imaginable, I was genuinely intrigued by the possibility of something different. Unfortunately, what I discovered was a production that couldn’t quite decide whether it wanted to be a traditional holiday film or a full-fledged horror experience.

[Warning: spoilers from Ebenezer are below!]

A familiar Christmas nightmare in Ebenezer

Based on Charles Dickens’ beloved novella, Ebenezer follows Ebenezer Scrooge, a bitter, wealthy businessman who has little patience for Christmas, generosity, or human connection. On Christmas Eve, Scrooge receives an unexpected visit from the ghost of his former business partner, Jacob Marley, who warns him of the consequences awaiting him if he refuses to change his ways.

The Ghost of Christmas Present (Tramell Tillman) and Ebenezer (Johnny Depp). Ebenezer (Paramount Pictures).
The Ghost of Christmas Present (Tramell Tillman) and Ebenezer (Johnny Depp). Ebenezer (Paramount Pictures).

Throughout the night, Scrooge encounters three supernatural spirits who force him to confront his past, examine his present, and witness a terrifying vision of his possible future. Along the way, he must reckon with the relationships, decisions, and missed opportunities that transformed him into the miserable man he has become.

This adaptation attempts to embrace the supernatural elements of Dickens’ original story, introducing darker imagery and more unsettling encounters. However, despite a handful of changes, the familiar journey of redemption remains largely intact.

Johnny Depp or Captain Jack Sparrow?

Let’s address the elephant in the room: Johnny Depp’s portrayal of Ebenezer Scrooge. Depp is certainly no stranger to eccentric characters, and his ability to create unusual personalities has been a defining feature of his career. Unfortunately, his Scrooge frequently reminded me of an elderly Captain Jack Sparrow. Between the exaggerated mannerisms, peculiar delivery, and overall characterization, I struggled to separate the performance from Depp’s previous work.

Rather than discovering a fresh interpretation of one of literature’s most recognizable characters, I felt like I was watching another familiar Depp personality dressed in Victorian clothing. That’s particularly disappointing considering the talented ensemble surrounding him, including Rupert Grint, Sam Claflin, Daisy Ridley, Andrea Riseborough, Tramell Tillman, and Ian McKellen. With that much recognizable talent involved, I expected considerably more from the overall experience.

Perhaps my biggest frustration with Ebenezer was its inability to establish a consistent identity. I understand the creative direction. A Christmas Carol is, after all, a ghost story. There are plenty of opportunities to explore its darker themes, frightening imagery, and psychological torment. With Ti West, known for films like X, Pearl, and MaXXXine, directing, I anticipated a much more committed approach to the horror genre. Instead, approximately 80% of the film felt like nearly every other adaptation of A Christmas Carol I’ve encountered. Occasionally, the movie introduces a particularly disturbing image or unsettling sequence, seemingly reminding audiences that this is supposed to be a darker interpretation. Then, almost as quickly, it returns to familiar holiday storytelling.

The result is a frustrating tonal inconsistency. For families hoping to enjoy a traditional Christmas movie, some of the darker material may feel unnecessarily disturbing. Meanwhile, horror fans hoping for a genuinely frightening reinterpretation may be disappointed by how conventional most of the film remains. It’s almost as though the filmmakers attempted to appeal to both audiences without fully satisfying either. And while blending genres can produce extraordinary results, it requires a clear creative vision that I simply didn’t find here.

Final Verdict: Bah, Humbug. Ebenezer’s one to skip

Ultimately, Ebenezer feels like a missed opportunity. There’s certainly potential in exploring the horror elements of A Christmas Carol, particularly with an accomplished horror director and an ensemble of recognizable actors.

Unfortunately, the film never fully commits to that premise. Between Depp’s distracting characterization, the inconsistent tone, and a storyline that offers little beyond what audiences have already experienced countless times, I walked away feeling underwhelmed. If you’re looking for a heartwarming holiday classic, there are better adaptations. If you’re looking for a terrifying Christmas horror film, there are better options there, too. Perhaps the greatest disappointment is that Ebenezer attempts to offer something for everyone, yet struggles to deliver enough for anyone. For me, this one is an easy SKIP. And considering how many versions of A Christmas Carol I’ve enjoyed over the years, that’s a particularly unfortunate verdict.

Ebenezer opened in theaters nationwide on November 13, 2026, through Paramount Pictures. Directed by Ti West and starring Johnny Depp, the film runs approximately 1 hour and 56 minutes and is rated PG-13 for frightening material. Due to its darker supernatural imagery, parents should consider whether the film is appropriate for younger viewers. For trailers, local showtimes, and tickets, visit the official Ebenezer website or Paramount Pictures.

Book Review: A Christmas Carol by Charles Dickens

A Christmas Carol by Charles Dickens Banner

Share this with a friend!